Intense Debate at Barça Over the Model: Perspectives from Former Players

A profound debate is unfolding at Barça concerning the club’s model, with former players from different eras providing insights to SPORT on the current state of the club. The essence of the club—its style, DNA, and identity—is under scrutiny.

As Pep Guardiola once remarked, “Now that we’re winning, the model seems good. It’s not questioned. But we won’t win forever. Doubts will arise. That will be the moment when we must trust the model more than ever because the temptation to deviate from it will be very strong.” Barcelona is facing challenging times economically, and it is impacting the sporting situation.

Tente Sánchez (1975-1986): Tente Sánchez, who played alongside Johan Cruyff, reflects on the style of play in the late ’70s. He emphasizes the importance of maintaining the attacking model but acknowledges that success depends on the quality of the players. He cautions against overreliance on youth players and warns about potential repercussions.

Ramon Calderé (1981-1988): Ramon Calderé, who experienced the Barça Atlètic and worked with Terry Venables, asserts that the model, rooted in Cruyff’s era, should not be altered. While praising the attractiveness of Barça’s style, he suggests an evolution, highlighting the need for more dynamism in positional play.

Pichi Alonso (1982-1986): Hero of Goteborg, Pichi Alonso, criticizes the current resemblance of Xavi’s Barça to a previous unsuccessful period. He emphasizes the importance of defensive solidity and pressing high, expressing concerns about the team defending too deep.

Jordi Roura (1983-1991): Jordi Roura, former player and director of the youth academy, stresses the significance of preserving the club’s DNA and identity. He advocates for a coach who understands the club’s values and suggests being realistic about short-term results to solidify a long-term project.

Lluís Carreras (1988-1993): Lluís Carreras, a staunch supporter of Cruyffism, emphasizes the non-negotiable aspects of Barça’s philosophy. He calls for an update and improvement of the model while preserving the fundamental idea. Carreras expresses doubts about the current application of the model due to player departures and an inability to find the right formula.

Jofre Mateu (1995-2000/01-02): Jofre Mateu challenges the notion that playing with two wingers is necessary to maintain the Barça model. He argues for adapting the structure while retaining positional play. Mateu highlights the importance of choosing a coach wisely, stating that bringing in someone like Klopp would signify a significant shift in the model.

The former players collectively stress the need for a careful balance between maintaining the essence of Barça’s style and adapting to the evolving landscape of football. The choice of the next coach is seen as pivotal in determining the club’s future trajectory.